Book Review: The Wrong Bachelor (The Wrong Match) by Janelle Stalder
There’s something undeniably exciting about young adult fiction, especially when it’s wrapped in the dazzle of high school drama, a touch of romance, and a pinch of rivalry. When I stumbled across The Wrong Bachelor by Janelle Stalder, I was immediately drawn in by the intriguing title and the promise of a chaotic dating competition. After all, who doesn’t enjoy a story where opposites clash, hearts race, and unexpected alliances form?
Seventeen-year-old Madison (Madi) Matthews is the epitome of a reluctant participant in this whirlwind. Voted into a fundraising dating competition as one of the ten "lucky" contestants, Madi has no interest in vying for the attention of Lincoln High’s heartthrob, Cole Kingston—her sworn enemy. Madi’s reluctance to chase boys is relatable; she seems perfectly content focusing her energy elsewhere, but the competitive environment shifts the dynamic in ways she never anticipated. Stalder captures teenage angst and distrust with relatable authenticity, leaving readers rooting for Madi during her internal struggle.
As the rivalry heats up, Cole Kingston’s charming exterior begins to reveal its cracks. Stalder does a fantastic job of painting Cole as the quintessential bad boy—good looks, athletic prowess, and a tendency to flirt like it’s an Olympic sport. However, there’s more beneath his cocky surface. I found myself fascinated by the slow unraveling of his character as Madi’s walls gradually come down. Their on-page tension is palpable, filled with sharp banter and sly glances that had me giggling and gasping in equal measure.
The writing style in The Wrong Bachelor is engaging and flows smoothly, making it easy to dive into Madi’s world. Stalder’s ability to balance humor with deeper themes of self-discovery and the complexities of teenage relationships gives the narrative a refreshing structure. I particularly appreciated how the pacing mirrored a high school day—busy yet punctuated with moments of stillness, reflective conversations, and, of course, the inevitable dramatic reveal at the school dance.
One memorable quote that stuck with me was, “Sometimes the wrong choices lead you to the right places.” This sentiment captured Madi’s journey perfectly—her path is filled with missteps and surprises, ultimately revealing the true nature of love and vulnerability. It’s a reminder that sometimes we need to navigate through the chaos to find clarity.
I believe The Wrong Bachelor is perfectly suited for anyone who enjoys contemporary romance, especially fans of enemies-to-lovers tropes. It’s an ideal read for teens navigating their own high school experiences, but also for adults who wish to revisit the sweetness and complications of first love. Though it’s part of a trilogy, it stands alone well, allowing readers to indulge without feeling overwhelmed.
Reflecting on my reading experience, I was pleasantly reminded of the thrill of young love, the importance of friendships, and the courage it takes to confront our adversaries—both on and off the field. Janelle Stalder has crafted a light-hearted yet thought-provoking story that lingers long after you turn the final page. So, if you’re ready to dive into a world of charm, rivalry, and self-discovery, I wholeheartedly encourage you to pick up The Wrong Bachelor. You won’t regret it!