Book Review: If I Stay by Gayle Forman
What draws you into a story sometimes hinges on its ability to tug at your heartstrings and resonate with your own life experiences. For me, If I Stay by Gayle Forman did just that. The premise—a young girl grappling with the harrowing choice of life and death after a tragic accident—immediately hooked my attention. As I dove into Mia Hall’s journey, I found myself tangled in a web of emotions, moments of beauty, and soul-searching dilemmas.
If I Stay masterfully blends themes of love, loss, and the tough choices we face in life. Mia’s story is both heartbreaking and inspiring. She navigates the aftermath of a tragic accident that claims her family, leaving her in an out-of-body experience, deciding whether to stay or let go. Through Mia’s journey, we are reminded of the profound connections we make in life—not just with those we love, but with our passions and our identities. The way Forman explores Mia’s love for music—so intricately woven into her being—adds another layer of depth to the narrative.
I couldn’t help but feel a spark of admiration for the way the characters were developed. Mia, Adam, and even her parents felt distinct and vibrant. The relationships, especially between Mia and her parents, struck me as both genuine and poignant. There’s a beautiful scene described with such vivid imagery:
“And there was so much noise. A symphony of grinding, a chorus of popping, an aria of exploding, and finally, the sad clapping of hard metal cutting into soft trees.”
These crafted moments made me appreciate Forman’s writing, though I must admit, I often found myself waging an internal debate between Nice Natalie and Cynical Natalie. While the prose was indeed breathtaking, Cynical Natalie could not help but point out that it lacked the emotional gravity needed to truly floor me—a criticism echoed in conversations with friends who felt similarly detached despite the surface-level beauty.
However, the pacing of the story felt awkward at times. My moment of connection was disrupted by moments that seemed long-winded, almost like a prologue to somethinggreater. While I appreciated the flashbacks that colored Mia’s memories, sometimes they felt like drifting through a sea of nostalgia without the urgency I craved in a pivotal life-and-death narrative. Cynical Natalie would chime in here, pointing out how Mia often seemed passive in her situation, as if the plot was leading her rather than the other way around.
The memorable moments and quotes did, in many ways, resonate with me. For instance, the awkward yet heartfelt scene between Mia and Adam, where he jokingly compares her to a cello, showcased first love’s naive intricacies. It was beautifully written, yet I shared Cynical Natalie’s sentiment of it being slightly cringe-worthy. Such nuances made Mia’s journey relatable, highlighting the bittersweet awkwardness of adolescence, even in dire situations.
If I Stay is undoubtedly a mixed bag, beautifully crafted yet somewhat uneven in execution. It invites deep reflection and personal evaluation of love and loss. For those who enjoy young adult narratives filled with emotional depth and explorative themes of self-discovery, this book holds substantial appeal. It resonates particularly well with readers who appreciate character-driven stories, even if some aspects leave them wanting more.
In conclusion, while If I Stay won’t necessarily leave a lingering legacy in my reading journey, it has undoubtedly struck a chord. It’s a poignant reminder of what it means to truly live and to love fiercely—even in the face of insurmountable pain. Whether you’re a fan of heartfelt contemporary YA fiction or simply in search of a thought-provoking read, Forman’s narrative might just spark your interest. It’s one of those novels that prompts discussions about its emotional handles, lending itself well to lively dialogues and reflections.
Discover more about If I Stay (If I Stay, #1) on GoodReads >>