Book Review: The Magical Imperfect by Chris Baron
There’s a unique magic that often draws us back to the stories of our youth, even when we’re undoubtedly past the Middle Grade age range. That’s precisely what Chris Baron’s The Magical Imperfect did for me—a breath of nostalgia interlaced with heartfelt themes that linger long after the last page. Winning this book in a giveaway felt serendipitous, especially as I prepared for a Zoom interview with Baron. Little did I know, this delightful return to Middle Grade would be one of those reading experiences that stays with you.
Set in 1989, The Magical Imperfect follows young Etan, who struggles with selective mutism after his mother’s extended hospital stay. Living with his grandfather and distant father, he wrestles with feelings of isolation while waiting for his mother’s return. Enter Malia, a young girl living nearby with severe eczema and a love for singing but unable to enjoy the outside world for fear of her condition. The bond that blossoms between them becomes the backbone of this poignant narrative.
One of the striking features of this book is its writing style, which is presented in verse. At first, I was unsure how this would resonate, but I found it refreshing and introspective. Baron’s choice to write in free verse wonderfully captures the emotional nuances of each scene. The presentation—where dialogue is indented differently based on who’s speaking—creates an almost musical rhythm. It made the narrative feel like a dance of thoughts and feelings, a reflection of Etan’s internal struggles and growth. Perhaps this poetic format was intended to evoke deeper emotions, and it certainly succeeded in portraying the tender moments of friendship, pain, and joy.
What truly stood out to me was the dual journey of Etan and Malia, both yearning for their voices to be heard. Their endeavors—Etan wanting to reclaim his speech and Malia daring to sing for an audience—embody the universal desire for connection. They encourage each other to confront their fears, beautifully illustrating the message that listening to those around us can be both empowering and healing. Baron adeptly weaves in the theme of community, highlighting not just the friends and family we choose but also the shared heritage that binds them together, making it resonate deeply with readers.
As for the book’s emotional balance, I was struck by how effortlessly Baron navigates both uplifting and somber scenes. The story doesn’t shy away from difficult topics—Etan’s father grappling with grief, their Jewish faith interspersed in their lives—but these aspects never feel overwhelming. Instead, they blend seamlessly into the narrative, allowing readers of all ages to engage meaningfully with the characters’ experiences.
In a world that often feels distant and chaotic, The Magical Imperfect serves as both a reminder and a beacon of hope. It’s a story about healing, friendship, and the strength found in community. I believe this book will resonate with young readers exploring their identities as well as adults looking for a heartfelt tale that reminds us of the power of connection.
If you cherish stories that explore the complexity of emotions and relationships with grace and warmth, this book will surely enchant you. Chris Baron has crafted a tender narrative that lingers in the heart, reminding us all of the miracles—often unnoticed—that surround us. So go ahead, immerse yourself in Etan and Malia’s world; you might just find a spark of magic waiting for you too.