Book Review: The Vincent Boys by Abbi Glines
When I stumbled upon The Vincent Boys buried in my e-library, my curiosity piqued. I honestly couldn’t recall whether it was a freebie or something I snagged during a Kindle sale. Intrigued—and perhaps a bit wary—I decided to dive in, hoping for more than just a typical New Adult (NA) romp. After all, this novel has seen its fair share of buzz (and considerable critique), so I was ready to explore what Abbi Glines had cooked up.
From the first pages, we meet Ashton, a preacher’s daughter who appears to lead a picture-perfect life—good grades, a doting boyfriend, and a seemingly flawless family. Yet, beneath the polished surface, Ash grapples with her longing to break free from her “good girl” persona. Enter Beau, the local bad boy and her childhood friend. Their rekindled friendship leads to a chaotic whirlwind of desire and deception, juxtaposing teenage angst with mature dilemmas that often felt oddly disjointed.
What struck me most was how the characters often felt much older than their supposed high school status. Their decisions—particularly the heavily dramatized romantic entanglements—were rife with melodrama and clichés, leading me to a heady confusion of empathy and irritation. Ash’s struggle with her identity and the allure of the “bad boy” trope made for an engaging foundation, but too often it spiraled into unconvincing turns, leaving a taste of frustration in my mouth.
Glines’s writing style is undeniably approachable, and I found myself flipping through pages with surprising speed. The pacing was effective, pulling me in despite my discomfort with the characters and their decisions. I think what nudged my rating up beyond a mere 1-star was the fact that Glines managed to weave a story that held my attention—even when I was busy shaking my head at the ridiculousness of some of the scenarios.
That said, I couldn’t overlook the troubling themes that simmered beneath the surface: instances of slut-shaming, sexual harassment, and a troubling depiction of relationships that often felt predatory. These moments overshadowed whatever attempts the characters made at growth or maturity, and I often felt manipulated by the narrative more than anything else. The casual misogyny left me feeling disheartened, particularly in a genre that promises to explore emotional evolution and complexity.
While I wouldn’t highly recommend The Vincent Boys, I can see its appeal for readers who enjoy dramatic NA love stories and don’t mind the complexities of morally ambiguous characters. It may resonate with readers who appreciate the highs and lows of teenage relationships, even if they don’t always find the resolutions satisfying.
Ultimately, this experience was a rollercoaster; it fostered reflections on the twists and pitfalls of young adulthood, even if the characters had me on the verge of tossing my e-reader more than once. I left the story not entirely satisfied but strangely thankful for the time spent—an opportunity to grapple with narrative choices that, while unsavory, opened my eyes to the messy realities of youth. So if you’re intrigued by stories that mix chaos with romance and are unafraid of melodrama, The Vincent Boys might just find a cozy spot on your shelf.
Overall score: 1.5/5
Discover more about The Vincent Boys (The Vincent Boys, #1) on GoodReads >>
