Not Crushing on the Cowboy: A Coming of Age Romance – A Review
There’s something irresistibly magnetic about a coming-of-age story, especially when it’s wrapped in the charm of small-town life and the complexities of young romance. "Not Crushing on the Cowboy" by Jessica F. Donohue immediately piqued my interest, not just for its title—which implies a playful tension—but for its promise of personal growth, familial relationship dynamics, and the intoxicating world of young love. As someone who often feels nostalgic about those awkward teenage years filled with cringe-worthy moments and heartfelt revelations, I was eager to dive into Penny Wilson’s world.
Unpacking a Young Queen Bee’s Journey
At its heart, this story centers around Penny, a high school senior who finds herself tumbling down the social ladder following her breakup with her longtime boyfriend. Donohue expertly captures the delicate balancing act of adolescence: the pressures of popularity, the quest for self-identity, and the chaos of emotions that come with it. The plot unfolds beautifully as Penny grapples with her feelings about her ex, her relationship with her father, and her unexpected connection to Ty Jackson, a rodeo cowboy hired to help at her family’s horse farm.
Penny’s character is refreshingly relatable. She starts off with a strong persona, but as the story progresses, we witness her vulnerabilities regarding identity and acceptance—a reminder that everyone, queen bee or not, grapples with self-doubt. Her interactions with Ty, the handsome yet humble cowboy, are delightful and often filled with a playful banter that had me smiling throughout. Ty’s dedication not just to his work but to helping Penny find her footing with her horse adds layers to his character, transforming him from a mere romantic interest into a genuine friend and mentor.
Writing Style and Pacing
Donohue’s writing style is engaging and flows seamlessly, allowing readers to breathlessly accompany Penny through her trials and triumphs. The pacing is spot on; while the romance simmers and evolves naturally, the exploration of Penny’s emotional landscape is rich and thoughtful. The dialogues sparkle with authenticity, showcasing the awkwardness of teenage interactions while still being refreshingly witty.
I also appreciated the vivid imagery when Penny interacts with her horses, which served not only as a backdrop to the romance but as a metaphor for her own journey and struggles. The connection between rider and horse expertly mirrors her evolving relationship with Ty—a beautifully crafted theme that resonated with me on many levels.
Memorable Moments and Quotes
While I found many moments delightful, one quote in particular struck a chord: "Sometimes, letting go is the bravest thing you can do." It encapsulates not just Penny’s journey towards healing, but a universal truth that all readers can relate to—whether at sixteen or sixty. This line lingered long after I finished reading, prompting reflections on my own experiences with letting go.
A Heartfelt Recommendation
"Not Crushing on the Cowboy" is a delightful read for anyone who enjoys young adult romance intertwined with themes of self-discovery and familial bonds. It will resonate particularly with teens navigating their own identities and relationships, but adults will find themselves touched by the nostalgia of youthful love and the importance of finding one’s worth beyond popularity.
In conclusion, this book reminded me of the importance of authenticity and bravery, and what it truly means to embrace ourselves fully. Jessica F. Donohue has penned a charming story that is not only entertaining but poignant—a perfect addition to any bookshelf! Whether you’re in the mood for a sweet romance or a thoughtful exploration of youth, this book is certainly worth picking up.
You can find Not Crushing on the Cowboy: A Coming of Age Romance here >>






